Discipline: the rules you do not break
Discipline here means three short lists: one before the session, one during, one after. You write them once and follow them without editing them mid-trade. The FSCA regulates brokers in South Africa, but it does not choose your rules for you. That part is yours. Payment methods such as EFT, instant EFT and bank cards affect how fast your money moves, not how well you trade, so they are not part of the routine.
Why the same routine works on a day you feel certain and a day you feel flat
A written routine replaces a decision with a check. On a USD/ZAR chart near 18.4100 the price moves all day, and each move invites a fresh opinion. If every order starts with a fresh opinion, the quality of your trading depends on your mood. A list removes the mood from the moment of entry. You read the line, you answer it, and you move on.
The reason this matters is that feelings arrive before facts. A losing streak makes the next setup look worse than it is. A winning run makes the next setup look better. Neither feeling changes the chart. The list does not try to remove the feeling. It simply asks whether the conditions you wrote down are present. If they are, the trade is allowed. If they are not, it is not.
Consistency also gives you something to review. If you change your rules each week, you cannot tell whether a bad month came from the rules or from the market. A routine that stays the same turns your results into information. You can then change one line at a time, on a quiet evening, and see what happens next.
What belongs on the before, during and after lists
The before list is about the world outside the order. It holds the things you can check in a minute: the day's economic calendar for South Africa and the United States, the spread on USD/ZAR, and whether you have time to watch the position. It also holds one personal line, such as how many hours you slept or whether you are trading to recover a loss. That last line is the one most people skip.
The during list is shorter, because you should not be reading much while an order is live. It holds the stop, the target, and the maximum number of trades for the day. It also holds one instruction for the moment you want to interfere: close the platform and do the after list first. The stop is fixed when the order opens. Nothing on the chart during the trade changes it.
The after list is where the learning happens. Write the entry, the exit, the result in rand, and one sentence on whether you followed the list. Do not write whether the trade was good or bad. A trade that lost money can be a good trade if the list was followed. A trade that made money can be a bad one if the list was ignored. The rand figure is only one of the two records.
Keep all three lists on one page. If they run to two pages, they are too long to use. The point is not to cover every situation. The point is to cover the situations that repeat, so that the repeated part of your day is already decided.
How the routine holds when two losses arrive
Two losses in a row are normal. On a USD/ZAR position of 0.10 lots, one pip is worth about R0.10, so a 50-pip stop is roughly R5.00 before costs. Two of those is about R10.00. The number is small, but the feeling is not, because the second loss arrives while the first is still fresh. This is the moment the routine is built for.
The routine answers with a count, not a judgement. If your during list says three trades a day, then two losses leave one trade. That is arithmetic, not opinion. The third trade uses the same stop and the same size as the first two. If the count is used up, the day is over, whatever the chart is doing. You can still watch. You cannot open another order.
If the urge to move a stop appears, the after list comes first. Write the entry, the exit and the result. Then read the line about the maximum number of trades. By the time you have written three lines, the urge has usually lost its urgency. If it has not, close the platform for the day. The market opens again tomorrow, and your rules will still be there.
What the broker controls and what you control
Your broker sets the spread, any commission, and the pip value it shows on your platform. Those figures vary between brokers, and they can vary between account types at the same broker. The FSCA regulates brokers in South Africa, but it does not set your stop, your size or your daily count. That part is yours, and no regulator can do it for you.
Payment methods such as EFT, instant EFT and bank cards decide how fast money reaches your account or leaves it. They do not change whether a trade is a good one. A fast deposit does not make a bad setup better. Treat funding as a separate task with its own list, done when the market is closed.
Before you trade, check the pip value your own platform shows for USD/ZAR. It may be rounded, and the spread may sit on top of it. The figures in this lesson are examples, not quotes. Write your own numbers on your own page, and update them when your broker changes them.
The five checks before one USD/ZAR order
The five checks below are the before list in action. They take about a minute. Do them in order, and do not skip a line because the setup looks obvious. The obvious ones are where the count gets used up fastest.
Each check has a yes or no answer. A no means no order, not a smaller order. If you find yourself negotiating with a check, that is the signal to stop for the day and write the after list instead.
The after list, written while the screen is still open
The after list is the only part of the routine that produces a record. Write it before you close the platform, while the numbers are still visible. Four lines are enough: entry, exit, result in rand, and whether the list was followed.
Read the last line first. If the list was followed, the trade is finished, whatever the result. If it was not, write which line you broke and what you will do differently next time. One line, not a paragraph. The next session will test it.
Keeping the page the same for a month
Change the routine on a quiet evening, never during a session. One change at a time, and keep the old page. After a month, compare the two. If the change helped, keep it. If it did not, put the old line back.
The routine is not a promise that you will never break a rule. It is a way of noticing sooner. The aim is a smaller gap between the rule and the action, not a perfect record.
A worked example with the numbers on the page
You plan 40 pips on 0.20 lots of USD/ZAR, with one pip worth about R0.10 per 0.10 lots. One pip is therefore about R0.20, and 40 pips is about R8.00. On an R8,000.00 account that is 0.1%.
Three losses of R5.00 in one day total R15.00. On an R5,000.00 account that is 0.3%. The routine does not change these sums. It keeps the sums from growing after the second loss.
Write your own account size and your own pip value at the top of the page. Then the numbers are yours, not examples.
5 checks before one USD/ZAR trade
| Step | Amount | Note |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Direction written down | USD/ZAR at 18.4100 | Price quoted from the platform at the time you look |
| 2. Entry and stop distance | 50 pips | Chosen by you before the order, not after |
| 3. Money at risk | R5.00 | 0.10 lots x 50 pips x about R0.10 per pip |
| 4. Account balance | R5,000.00 | Balance shown by your broker |
| 5. Risk as a share of the account | 0.1% | R5.00 divided by R5,000.00, then multiplied by 100 |
Your broker may round the pip value, charge a spread or commission on top, and quote a slightly different USD/ZAR price. These figures vary between brokers, so check your own platform before you trade.
Doing it once, step by step
Work through these five checks once, in order, before you open a single USD/ZAR order. The order matters, because each check can end the process.
- 01
Check the calendar
Look at the economic calendar for South Africa and the United States. Note any release due within the next hour. If a release is close, no order. Wait until the price has settled after the number.
- 02
Check the spread
Read the spread your platform shows on USD/ZAR. Compare it with the spread you usually see at that hour. If it is wider than normal, the cost of the trade has changed. A wider spread means a smaller effective stop, so no order until it returns to normal.
- 03
Check the stop and the size
Write the stop in pips and the size in lots before you open the order. On 0.10 lots, one pip is about R0.10, so a 50-pip stop is roughly R5.00 before costs. If that rand figure is more than your written maximum for one trade, reduce the size.
- 04
Check the count
Count the trades you have already taken today. If the count has reached your written maximum, the day is over. Close the platform and do the after list.
- 05
Check yourself
Answer one personal line: are you trading to recover a loss, or because the setup is on the list. If the answer is recovery, no order. Write the after list and stop for the day.
- 06
Write the after list
After the order closes, write the entry, the exit, the result in rand, and whether the list was followed. Read the last line first. If a line was broken, write which one and one change for next time.
The mistake most people make here
The common mistake is to write rules and then rewrite them in the middle of a losing trade, usually by moving the stop further away to avoid taking the loss. That turns a planned R5.00 loss into something much larger, and it happens because the decision is made while the money is moving. Instead, write the five checks before you open the order, and treat the stop as fixed once the order is live. If you feel the urge to move it, close the platform and do the after-session list first.Check yourself
You plan 40 pips on 0.20 lots of USD/ZAR, with one pip worth about R0.10 per 0.10 lots. What is the money at risk?
0.20 lots is twice 0.10 lots, so one pip is about R0.20. 40 pips x R0.20 = R8.00.
Your account is R8,000.00 and you risk R8.00. What share of the account is that?
R8.00 divided by R8,000.00 is 0.001. Multiply by 100 to get 0.1%.
You take three losses of R5.00 in one day. What is the total, and what is it as a share of a R5,000.00 account?
3 x R5.00 = R15.00. R15.00 divided by R5,000.00 is 0.003, or 0.3%.
Questions that come up next
I wrote my before list, but I skipped the sleep line and traded anyway. Does one skipped line matter?
One skipped line matters because the list is a check, not a menu. The sleep line exists to catch the day you are least able to follow the other lines. If you skip it, the rest of the list is being read by someone who is tired, and tired reading is where the stop gets moved. Write the line, answer it, and if the answer is poor, do not open the order. The skipped line is the early warning, not the failure.
My during list says the stop is fixed. What do I actually do in the minute I want to move it?
Close the platform first, then do the after list. The urge to move a stop is strongest while the price is moving and you are watching it. Closing the platform removes the moving number from your view. The after list then asks whether you followed the list, and the answer is usually no. You can reopen the platform after that, but by then the decision has been made on paper rather than on the chart.
How many trades should the during list allow in one day?
The number is yours to set, and it should be small enough that you can still follow the list on the last one. A common approach is to write a maximum before the session and treat it as fixed, the same way the stop is fixed. If you reach the maximum, the day is over regardless of how the last trade ended. The number varies between people, so there is no correct figure to copy.
My after list says the result in rand. Should I also write whether the trade was good?
Write whether you followed the list, not whether the trade was good. A trade that lost R5.00 can be a good trade if every line was followed. A trade that made R50.00 can be a bad one if the stop was moved. The rand figure is one record and the list check is the other. Keeping both is what makes the after list useful.
I changed one line of my routine in the middle of a losing week. Was that wrong?
Changing a line is not wrong in itself. Changing it while a trade is live, or straight after a loss, is the problem, because the change is made by the same mood that produced the loss. Set the change aside and review it on a quiet evening with no order open. Then change one line only, and watch what happens over the next few weeks. One line at a time is what turns your results into information.
Does my broker's spread change what my before list should say?
Yes. The spread on USD/ZAR varies between brokers and can widen around news. Your before list should include a look at the spread on your own platform before you open an order. The pip value figures used in this course are examples, and your broker may round them or charge commission on top. Check your own platform, because the numbers there are the ones that apply to you.
The words used on this page
- Routine
- A short written list you read the same way every session. It replaces a fresh opinion at the moment of entry with a check you already agreed to.
- Stop
- The price at which an open position is closed to limit the loss. Once the order is live, the stop is fixed and the chart does not change it.
- Spread
- The gap between the price at which you can buy and the price at which you can sell. It is a cost on every trade, and it varies between brokers and around news.
- Pip
- A small unit of price movement on a currency pair. On USD/ZAR, one pip is worth about R0.10 per 0.10 lots, though your broker may round it.
- FSCA
- The Financial Sector Conduct Authority, which regulates brokers in South Africa. It does not choose your personal trading rules. That part is yours.
- Loss streak
- Several losing trades in a row. A streak makes the next setup look worse than it is, which is why the list asks about conditions rather than feelings.
What to take away
- A written routine turns a decision into a check, so the quality of your trading does not depend on your mood.
- Keep three short lists on one page: before, during and after. If they need two pages, they are too long to use.
- The stop is fixed when the order opens. If you want to move it, close the platform and do the after list first.
- Record the result in rand and whether you followed the list. A losing trade can be a good trade, and a winning trade can be a bad one.